after the Epiphany
| Old Testament | 1 Samuel 3:1–10 (11–20) |
| Psalm | Psalm 139:1–5, 12–17 |
| Epistle | 1 Corinthians 6:12–20 |
| Gospel | John 1:43–51 |
Almighty God, whose Son our Savior Jesus Christ is the light of the world: Grant that your people, illumined by your Word and Sacraments, may shine with the radiance of Christ’s glory, that he may be known, worshiped, and obeyed to the ends of the earth; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who with you and the Holy Spirit lives and reigns, one God, now and for ever.
I struggle to discern whether the voice I hear belongs to you or stems from my internal thoughts. Speak to me, even though my hearing may be delayed. Continue to call me even when I fail to immediately respond. I desire to believe you are calling me but I question why you would choose me. You reached out to Samuel even though he was still young. Maybe you call me too. Help me to trust that. Amen.
▶ | Hear These Lessons Preached Preached on Epiphany 3 in Year B — on the calling of the disciples; the nearest match in the archive to this Sunday’s “Come and see” |
“When a man conceals one thing in his heart, and speaks another, it is guile, and he has, as it were, two hearts. … If, then, guile was not in Nathanael, the Physician judged him to be curable, not whole. … He confesses that he is a sinner. For if he is a sinner, and says that he is a just man, there is guile in his mouth. Therefore in Nathanael He praised the confession of sin; He did not judge that he was not a sinner.”
“Nathanael then was under the fig-tree, as it were under the shadow of death. The Lord saw him… But you beheld His compassion before you knew Him, when you were lying under sin. For did we first seek Christ, and not He seek us? Did we come sick to the Physician, and not the Physician to the sick? … we seek you because we were sought; we wish to find you because we have been found.” And again: “O you Israel without guile, whosoever you are… before I called you by my apostles, when you were under the shadow of death, and you saw not me, I saw you.”
“Neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision, but faith that worketh by love.”
“Adeste fideles. That is the only answer I know for people who want to find out whether or not this is true. Come all ye faithful, and all ye who would like to be faithful if only you could, all ye who walk in darkness and hunger for light. Have faith enough, hope enough, despair enough, foolishness enough at least to draw near to see for yourselves.”
“What can we do to alleviate some of those fears that may well keep our neighbors and friends from coming to see Jesus for themselves?”
This week we shift across to one of our Johannine readings for the year. The passages in John’s Gospel, according to most scholars, follow a carefully crafted narrative that steers people away from the proclamation of John the Baptist and towards the revelation of Jesus.
The passage also tells of the calling of two disciples. Reading the whole account, you can see that they bear witness to Jesus as the Messiah, the Son of Man. In this theme we have the promised king of Israel presented in the holy titles being used — and at the same time the competing notion that such a vision of Jesus’ ministry is all too narrow.
Another theme has to do with the calling itself: the image of Philip and Nathanael, who, being seen by Jesus, are called by him; and then their own witness to Jesus. Seeing and proclaiming who he is, and revealing to the world that this is the one to come and see.
What has most intrigued me about this passage comes from Raymond Brown’s volume on John (vol. 1, 59ff): the images linked to this story from ancient Israel’s own story. Brown illustrates well, I think, that Jesus here is connected to the image of Jacob’s ladder, the divine chariot of Ezekiel, Bethel itself, and the rock on which Jacob laid his head. What a wonderful set of traditions — none of which, in and of themselves, is completely convincing scholastically. Nevertheless, I love them.
What really resonates with me, as I hold in tension the symbols floating in the text, the movement away from John the Baptist, and the seeing imagery of Philip and Nathanael, is that we have here a wonderful passage about Jesus as the center of Christian life and discipleship. Jesus is central, and he is out in the world for us to see.
We preachers spend a lot of time telling folks we don’t see Jesus. We don’t see Jesus in their actions, in their spending, in their lives. We don’t see Jesus in the church. We don’t see Jesus in the world.
Think about the last ten sermons you gave, and I wonder how many of them spent time telling people how we don’t see Jesus. In fact, I wonder whether the amount of preaching about not seeing Jesus in people’s lives has something to do with the number of people who don’t want to listen to us preach about not seeing Jesus, and so don’t come to church.
What if this Sunday we actually told our Episcopalians, and those who might be visiting with us, that we see Jesus? We see Jesus in them. We see Jesus in their lives and in their stories. We see Jesus out in the world. What if we made a concerted effort this Sunday not to give bad news, and tried to avoid telling people how we don’t see Jesus? What if this Sunday we gave them good news?
What if this Sunday we preachers were solidly about seeing Jesus Christ out in the world? If we, like Philip and Nathanael, were able to tell our neighbors, brothers, sisters, and fellow churchgoers that we see Jesus and we want them to see Jesus too?
It would be news if we and our churchgoers went looking for Jesus in the world and found him in places, images, and things — even in rocks — and said, “Look, here is God out in the world. Here is how God connects us. We call this connection to the Most High God: Jesus.” Generous and holy naming would become our work out in the world, and people would hear from us a new story, perhaps a story they have been longing to hear.
Our work as evangelists is not sitting around waiting for people to come into our churches and ask us to show them Jesus, and then, in some theological discourse via negativa, telling them where we don’t see Jesus. Or, worse, preaching to them about how they aren’t doing it right and how we don’t see Jesus at all in their lives or in the world.
“Our work is to go out and generously listen, generously name Jesus in the lives of others, and generously invite people to come and see.”
I wonder if we might together, as preachers and parishioners, promise that for the next month we will take on as our Epiphany discipline the work of seeing and announcing Jesus to those around us — and that we will do it with positive and affirming statements.
The Prayer Book’s Catechism will not let the body be a secondary matter. “Q. What are we by nature? A. We are part of God’s creation, made in the image of God. Q. What does it mean to be created in the image of God? A. It means that we are free to make choices: to love, to create, to reason, and to live in harmony with creation and with God.” Freedom is named as the image of God in the same breath as creatureliness — which is precisely Paul’s problem and Paul’s answer. The Corinthians are not wrong that they are free. They are wrong about what freedom is for.
“Paul stresses that the believer in Christ also belongs to that same Lord. There is no such thing as being one’s own. Each of us has commitments that bind us to other persons or ways of thinking and living.”
“Paul regularly shifts our focus from morality to relationships, just as he shifts our focus from law to freedom. But his notion of freedom is wise to issues of power and confronts the splitting and compartmentalization which refuses to let God be God and love be love in everything.”
This is a very important passage in the discussion of grace. Paul’s take, simply put, is this: “All things are lawful for me,” but not all things are beneficial. “All things are lawful for me,” but I will not be dominated by anything.
Rowan Williams once said to me: we don’t experiment with our bodies.
Certainly Paul is not speaking to our particular issues and culture wars. Paul is speaking specifically to Corinth, which was not a healthy place. It was a licentious place.
They had perhaps embraced freedom too much. It is not that we aren’t free; it is that not all things are good for the body or good for the community. As Chris Haslam puts it, Paul quotes a slogan from his opponents — “All things are lawful for me” — and does not disagree, for Christian living does not depend on observing a set of rules but on God, who accepts even those who break his laws. But he adds a qualification: some things may not be beneficial, for the person or in the community.
The issue for Paul is when the individual is enslaved by their indulgence. Christian liberty is not a license to destroy one’s own body or another’s. It is not a license to be disruptive, or to destroy a community for the sake of your own beliefs.
When we are too focused on our will, our want, and our desire, we are taking our focus away from God.
We are not only in a spiritual relationship with God but also a physical one. Overeating, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, sexual abuse — in fact any abuse of the body, though it will be remade in the resurrection — is a chasm created between God and ourselves.
We are not separate bodies and then separate spirits. We are intermingled, entwined. Our lives are as well. There is no secular and profane set over against the sacred, but instead a great connection of all things — and that connection is intimately tied to God too.
I believe all of us would agree that Paul’s understanding of how the body works is a bit outdated. We know more about how we work, how our bodies get their shape, and how they go together with other bodies. We have new thoughts about what a person is and how that person is truly connected to body and spirit. None of this new thinking — important, and very different from first-century biology and psychology — lessens Paul’s clarity that, while we are free because of God’s grace, our freedom is not always good for us.
“The preacher this week has an opportunity to reclaim this passage from the sexual and cultural debates of our time, and to talk instead about re-engaging a spirituality that includes the body.”
The Prayer Book’s own call-and-send collect sits one Sunday after this one, and it asks for exactly what Samuel is given in the dark: “Give us grace, O Lord, to answer readily the call of our Savior Jesus Christ and proclaim to all people the Good News of his salvation, that we and the whole world may perceive the glory of his marvelous works.” Note the word readily. Samuel answers three times before he knows whom he is answering. Readiness, in the Prayer Book’s grammar, comes before clarity.
“The Lord was with Samuel, but somehow this divine appointment does not at all diminish the totality of the human experience.”
“Tradition is the living faith of the dead; traditionalism is the dead faith of the living.”
In our Episcopal tradition, the call of Samuel is one of those passages most frequently read at celebrations of a new ministry. And what happens is that we hijack the Scripture by making it about us and how much we are like Samuel. In this way we miss the message about the old existing religious tradition.
Let us think through the passage from a missional perspective, and try to envision a word for God’s church.
In a time when we flounder as a religion, it is hard to hear the word of the Lord. It becomes stale. It is a tradition of the dead instead of a living tradition (3:1). At such times it is hard for the people who are stuck to see; our eyesight, our vision, dims (3:2). Yet God is present, and people are listening. Typically they are different, younger, and eager (3:3).
Note that we know quite clearly part of what is happening: Eli’s sons are keeping the best of the offerings for themselves, and not passing them along to God and to the poor. Verse 13 is coming: “For I have told him that I am about to punish his house for ever, for the iniquity that he knew, because his sons were blaspheming God, and he did not restrain them.”
People who hear God’s calling in times like this can easily get everything confused, believing that it is the ancient tradition and religion that is calling. So we go, and we say: here we are. But the tradition says clearly, we did not call you. We are resting in our traditionalism.
The traditionalists sometimes have to be awakened several times by the visions and hearings of the young before they truly realize that God is not dead — that in fact God has come calling. And when the tradition, like Eli, awakes, it listens carefully.
Eli tells Samuel to listen, and he does so respectfully. He will then speak the words to Eli and offer the vision God has spoken. Eli receives the news faithfully: “So Samuel told him everything and hid nothing from him. Then he said, ‘It is the Lord; let him do what seems good to him’” (3:18). And we are told, now that Samuel has figured out how to listen anew, that the word is with him and none of it falls to the ground.
It will be Samuel’s work to give voice to the people’s cry for help and to God’s desire to comfort. He will preach against systems that abuse the weak. And when God gives in to the monarchy, Samuel will remind the monarchy that it is their work — indeed their calling — to seek the good of the people in their care, and to help God care for the weak, the powerless, and the hungry.
Callie Plunket-Brewton writes that just as the call of Samuel sets the tone for his prophetic career and foreshadows the oracles he will deliver against the human leaders of the people, so the song of Hannah represents the central focus of the Lord’s leadership of the people: concern for the poor and powerless, and judgment of those who prey on the vulnerable and abuse their power.
Samuel received a vision about religion which revealed to him that neither it nor the powers of this world may take advantage of the poor. Aging religions, aging monarchies, and aging governments lose sight of the fact that they are merely tools and vessels with an opportunity to do good. They have the power and authority to serve the weakest. So often they choose systems of death and corruption instead. So often they lose sight of the reign of God.
“Sometimes religions and principalities need new prophets to help them hear.”
Nathanael is praised for having no guile — which Augustine says means only that he does not claim to be well. What are you still pretending about, and to whom?
Jesus saw Nathanael under the fig tree before Nathanael knew there was anything to see. Where in your life have you been seen already, and only discovered it later?

